Lost SEO Traffic After Cookie Consent? Here’s How to Quantify It Like a Pro
Noticing a significant dip in your website’s search engine traffic after implementing cookie consent can be upsetting as it becomes more difficult to prove or disprove statements related to the efficiency of SEO practices implemented on a site by not being able to communicate this well to the stakeholders who are looking for the improvements within the reporting dashboards. We have been transitioning for some time into an age of digital landscapes governed by global privacy laws, which necessitate compliance but seem to obscure our view of actual site performance. As someone deeply entrenched in the dynamics of SEO, I’m faced the challenge of accurately quantifying the impact of these SEO changes.
The video below explains in detail an effective and proven method to estimate organic search traffic close enough to the actual numbers when cookie consent is disabled.
Large Organic Search Traffic Drop After Implementing The Cookie Consent Banner? You’re missing data, and you're not alone.
Implementing a cookie consent popup has become a balancing act between being GDPR cookie consent compliant and retaining the integrity of our SEO efforts. When I first integrated a cookie consent solution on my site, I was aware of the potential consequences but underestimated the extent to which it would affect organic search traffic. The requirement to block third-party cookies unless users explicitly give their consent for cookies to be stored on their device has fundamentally changed the way we collect data. Suddenly, Google Analytics was showing a significant drop in user engagement, not because fewer people were visiting, but because fewer were allowing their data to be tracked. Over the years, more privacy acts came out like the CCPA, and others that appear all have some shared characteristics, but with individual nuances that are difficult to remember, nor understand all the legal-speak, to the point where the implementation of the cookie consent is just easier to do by working with a cookie consent manager vendor that studied all the compliance details and you just need to use their system, like Ketch, Osano, OneTrust, and Cookiebot cookie consent management.
GDPR Cookie Consent Banner Requirements - The Interpretation of the Law
Not every company implements cookie consent in the same way. Some websites provide no clear option to decline cookies; instead, their messaging implies that if you do not wish to be tracked, you should leave the site. Others offer more granular control, allowing users to choose between accepting all cookies or only essential ones. Some include a “Decline All” option, but the default action, when no choice is made, may differ: in some cases, all cookies are accepted by default, while in others, the default is to decline all.
The way companies configure their cookie consent mechanisms is often based on their interpretation of privacy laws such as the GDPR or CCPA. However, in discussions I’ve had with client stakeholders and analytics professionals, particularly those who default to declining all cookies, they’ve cited legal advice as the driving factor. Importantly, this advice isn’t always grounded strictly in their own legal interpretation of the law, but often stems from a more conservative approach intended to minimize risk. Their concern lies in how the law might be interpreted by others, especially those who might initiate legal action. Thus, the configuration reflects not just compliance, but also risk mitigation and legal strategy.
How to Estimate Lost Organic Traffic and Conversions Using Normal Web Analytics Tools
Estimating Lost SEO Traffic from Cookie Consent Management
If you did not watch the video above and simply wants to know the formulas used. It is basically:
(Estimated Organic Search Traffic) = (GSC Clicks)
Note: GSC is Google Search Console, which provides click data specifically from Google’s search results.
You don’t need to use Google Analytics specifically for this calculation. Any web analytics platform will work, as long as it allows you to filter traffic by organic search, or at least by source and/or medium.
Adjusting for Non-Google Search Engines
However, organic search traffic doesn’t only come from Google. People also arrive through Bing, Yahoo, DuckDuckGo, and other search engines. So, to get a more accurate estimate of total organic traffic, you should factor in non-Google traffic using your current ratio of Google to non-Google organic sessions.
The adjusted formula becomes:
(Estimated Organic Search Traffic from GA)
= (GSC Clicks) + { [ (Non-Google Organic Search Traffic) / (Google Organic Search Traffic) ] * (GSC Clicks) }
Although we use the word traffic here, the actual metric may vary depending on your analytics platform:
- In Google Analytics, this usually refers to Sessions.
- In Adobe Analytics, the equivalent metric is Visits.
- In other platforms, use whichever metric most closely represents visit-level user activity from organic search.
Use the appropriate terminology and data points from your platform to maintain consistency in reporting.
Estimating Lost SEO Conversions due to a Cookie Consent Manager
So the first step in getting the estimated conversions is getting the estimated traffic above. And since we know that:
(Conversion Rate) = (Conversions) / (Traffic)
You will have a conversion rate already in your web analytics for people that accept the cookie consent. Just apply that conversion rate to the estimated traffic to get the conversions.
(Estimated Conversions) = (Estimated Traffic) * (Conversion Rate)
How accurate is this estimation method? Any Cookie Consent examples that show its accuracy?
I feel very confident in this method when we used the same formula on 2 client websites that had the default cookie consent to decline cookies if no selection was made. Since we had data before and after the cookie consent dialog box was, we saw how it trended with historical data before the cookie consent and showed some high correlation.
In the screenshot above, the estimated traffic values is the line graph, while the actual tracked is the column chart. The cookie consent dialog box was added in September 2024.
Similarly, below are the estimated conversions from organic search for the same website:
Frequently asked questions this method to analyze SEO traffic and conversions
After sharing my idea with colleagues and industry peers, I received several insightful questions, some of which you might be wondering about too.
Can this estimation of traffic and conversion lost from cookie consent be used for other marketing channels aside from SEO?
Like many SEO-related questions, the answer is: it depends.
In SEO, we’re fortunate to have Google Search Console (GSC), which gives us click data specifically from Google search, still the dominant search engine in many regions. This makes estimation relatively straightforward.
For other marketing channels, the applicability of this approach depends on the availability of click-level data. Many paid media platforms (like Google Ads, Meta Ads, LinkedIn, etc.) do report the number of ad clicks. So yes, a similar estimation method can be applied, as long as there’s a reliable click baseline and a corresponding analytics dataset (e.g., sessions, visits) to compare it to.
What factors influence how accurate this estimate is?
The biggest variable is the ratio of Google to non-Google organic search traffic, which can fluctuate over time.
The estimation relies on the current observed ratio between Google and other search engines. If that ratio remains stable, your estimate will be fairly accurate. But if the share of non-Google traffic changes due to seasonality, regional behavior, or shifts in user habits, the estimate could become less reliable. This potential fluctuation is the main source of error in the model.
Can't I just rely 100% on Google data? Why estimate traffic from other search engines?
You can, especially if Google accounts for the vast majority of your organic search traffic.
However, this isn’t always the case. In some markets or with certain demographics:
- Bing, Yahoo, or DuckDuckGo may hold a larger share.
- In specific countries (e.g., Russia with Yandex, China with Baidu), Google is not the dominant engine.
- Users who don’t change default settings (e.g., Windows users sticking with Bing) may skew your audience toward alternative search platforms.
If your target audience falls into one of these categories, estimating non-Google traffic becomes more important for getting a complete picture.
My website is not in the U.S., we have a different dominant search engine. Can this method still work?
Of course. As long as your web analytics platform correctly attributes organic search referral traffic, this approach still applies. Just substitute Google with the dominant search engine in your market.
Pro Tip: Google Analytics maintains a list of recognized search engines that it includes in the Organic Search channel. You can review this list to verify that your local engines are supported.
Stakeholders don’t believe the estimates. How can I build trust in the numbers?
A great way to demonstrate credibility is to compare pre-cookie-consent data (when tracking was complete) to your estimated data post-consent.
If your estimated trends closely mirror your historical actual data, particularly during consistent periods, stakeholders will be more likely to trust the model. Visualization of the overlap in a report can be particularly persuasive.
Can I just hide the data or obfuscate it when I implement cookie consent? Who is going to know?
While that might seem like a quick fix, it’s risky and unethical.
With regulations like the ePrivacy Directive, GDPR, and others, you have a legal obligation to handle data responsibly. It’s not just about avoiding detection, it’s about protecting your company, respecting your users, and maintaining transparency with stakeholders.
When companies get caught, the legal implications, penalties, and reputational damage often far outweigh the effort it would’ve taken to stay compliant in the first place.
How can I show this estimate automatically in a web analytics dashboard report?
There are multiple ways to implement this, depending on your reporting setup:
- If you’re using a data visualization or BI tool like Looker Studio (formerly Data Studio), Tableau, Power BI, or even Python for Data Science (pandas) dashboards, you can automate the calculation.
- Use APIs from Google Search Console and Google Analytics to fetch data programmatically.
- If you prefer manual workflows, you can export CSVs and use tools like Excel or Google Sheets, applying formulas to compute the estimates. But note that Google Search Console does not export data more than 1000 rows from their UI.
In short, the method is platform-agnostic; you can adapt it to fit your preferred tech stack.
Have you tried this with other websites with a cookie consent popup?
Yes, we ran it on several websites that have cookie consent. Here is another more recent screenshot for another website we are just going to start working with.
That was for the traffic, and here it is for the conversions.
Turning Lost Web Traffic Analytics Data Into Strategic Insights
Cookie consent banners aren’t going away no matter what cookie preferences you make and eventually, if you need to comply with GDPR in Europe, CPPA for California residents or other privacy acts from South Africa to laws around the world, and needs to run Google consent mode v2 for cookie law compliance, as an SEO, you will eventually need to notify users to have the freedom in accepting or rejecting cookie usage. The cookie banner that provides users to opt out of cookie tracking on a user’s device eanbles visitors to control what data is collected.
Obtaining consent a vital part of respecting privacy laws and user trust. But they’ve also introduced real challenges in measuring the true impact of SEO and other digital marketing efforts as these GDPR and eprivacy directive has caused a decrease in the collecting data. Fortunately, with a bit of smart estimation, we don’t have to fly blind.
By combining click data from Google Search Console with traffic data from your analytics platform, and adjusting for other search engines, you can reconstruct a fairly accurate picture of your lost organic traffic and the conversions tied to it, and still comply with GDPR cookie consent requirements. . This gives you the clarity you need to explain fluctuations to stakeholders, guide future SEO decisions, and maintain confidence in your performance metrics.
The goal isn’t to “guess” your data, it’s to bridge the gap responsibly, transparently, and as accurately as possible when dealing with the challenges of eprivacy regulation laws like the GDPR and CCPA.
Benj Arriola
Senior Director SEO @ 85SIXTY
Leave a comment:
You must be logged in to post a comment.